Home » Trade Marks » SkyDrive v Sky: Microsoft lose against BSkyB over the use of the term “Skydrive”

SkyDrive v Sky: Microsoft lose against BSkyB over the use of the term “Skydrive”

Keltie LLP

K2 IP Limited

About IPcopy

IPcopy is an intellectual property related news site covering a wide variety of IP related news and issues. We will also take the odd lighthearted look at IP. Feel free to contact us via the details on the About Us page.

Disclaimer: Unless stated otherwise, the contributors to IPcopy (the "IPcopy writers") are patent and trade mark attorneys or patent and trade mark assistants at Keltie LLP or are network attorneys at K2 IP Limited. Guest contributors will be identified.

This news site is the personal site of the contributors and is not edited by the authors' employer in any way. From time to time however IPcopy may publish practice notes, legal updates and marketing news from Keltie LLP or K2 IP Limited. Any such posts will be clearly marked.

This news site is for information purposes only. Information posted to this news site is not legal advice and should not be taken as such. If you require IP related legal advice please contact your legal representative.

For the avoidance of doubt Keltie LLP and K2 IP Limited have no liability as to the content of IPcopy and any related tweets or social media posts.

sky logoBSkyB, the British Satellite Broadcasting company has won a case against the American multinational software corporation (Microsoft) in actions for passing off and for infringement of two CTM Registrations and two UK trade mark registrations for SKY. By way of these actions, BSkyB sought to prevent Microsoft from using “SkyDrive” as the name for their cloud storage service in Europe.

In a counterclaim, Microsoft filed for a declaration of partial invalidity in respect of the SKY trade marks on the grounds of descriptiveness for cloud storage services.

Judge Justice Asplin held that although the average consumer “is a reasonably well informed and reasonably observant user of broadband internet services, if one undertakes a global assessment there is every reason to conclude that there is a likelihood of confusion”.

In light of other cases, the judge considered that “since it is accepted that “drive” is a descriptive term, just as in Alejandro v OHIM and Compass v Compass Logistics, the first syllable “Sky” must be seen as the dominant element of the mark and that there is a manifest likelihood of confusion on the part of the consumer with regard to the SkyDrive mark. Thus, the judge rejected Microsoft’s arguments that the average consumer would see SkyDrive as one word and would characterise it in the same way as VapoRub or BlackBerry. Moreover, the judge considered that “Sky” is an arbitrary trade mark and that the evidence submitted by Microsoft stating that “sky” was descriptive in the sense that it is allusive of the internet and that it is a common word used by traders to describe a cloud system are not consistent.

Sky’s claim under passing off submitted that the “classical trinity” of passing off also succeeded. The judge said that the existence of goodwill with regard to its considerable marketing budget was obvious. There is a misrepresentation that is likely to lead to confusion found in the above circumstances and “damage is inherently likely where frequently the customers of a business wrongly connect it with another”.

The next stage in this battle is an appeal in which Microsoft would wish to submit new arguments. Indeed, a Microsoft spokesman has said that “This case is only about the SkyDrive name and has nothing to do with service availability or future innovation. The decision is one step in the legal process and Microsoft intends to appeal.”

However, if Microsoft loses the appeal they may be forced to rename their product. Will Microsoft find new arguments to counterclaim in appeal? We look forward to finding out.

Amélie Gérard 31 July 2013

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: